I have a lot of thoughts about magic. Because I spend a lot of time thinking about it.
I often compare magic with other art forms to try and identify key differences that set magicians apart and to look for areas where we as mystery performers/magic-doers/whatever we call ourselves can improve the quality of our work as a community.
Here’s a problem I see with magic that goes to how exclusive it can feel sometimes. When you look at a field like visual arts, there are so many ways to “appreciate” it. A person can walk into a museum, go up to a painting and immediately say “I like it” or “I hate it” and walk away. And that’s a completely valid way to approach art (personal preferences).
But there are so many other groups with different ways of looking at it. Some people can walk up and examine the technique – looking at the composition and the brushstrokes and appreciate it from that perspective.
Other people might look at the historical context or physical location of the piece to look at it as a lens for cultural understanding.
And every spot on that spectrum from personal preference to codified learning is a valid way to look at it. Most importantly, this wide swath of ways to interact with visual arts means that there are loads of in-roads to experiencing it.
With magic, we feverishly guard our secret techniques. Our methods are only for magicians, and all the work that goes in behind the scenes is jealously protected. I completely understand that there’s a breaking point (where sharing the method of the trick as you’re doing it negates the experience of magic), but there have to be ways to make our art more inclusive for people searching for different perspectives and experiences.
We limit our audiences to one tiny end of the spectrum where they can – basically – only say “I liked that trick” or “I didn’t like it” and some justification that may or may not be informed by fact.
We make room for magicians to look at all the surrounding elements that make up our art, but I don’t think we’ll progress as far or as quickly as we could until we find thoughtful ways to open our community to non-magicians.
The more (varied) perspectives, the richer and more textured our art becomes!